Italian restaurants

Garramone's Restaurant

4.3 284 reviews Closed 11770 O Brien Rd, Forestport, NY 13338, United States

Discover this place

Nestled in the quiet charm of Forestport, NY, Garramone's Restaurant shines as a true gem in the Italian dining landscape. Patrons rave about its delicious offerings, making it a popular spot for family gatherings and special occasions. The restaurant's standout dishes include the renowned Trifecta, featuring a delightful trio of lobster tail, chicken parmesan, and steak, as praised by Neil Farber. Fans of veal will rejoice as well, with hearty veal parmesan also winning hearts. The chicken francaise and the beloved meatball tunnel have also received high accolades, showcasing Garramone's focus on rich flavors and hearty portions.

Though some reviews mention the need for a few upgrades to the interior and parking lot, the warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly service leave a lasting impression. Each meal begins with warm bread and a fresh salad, creating a comforting dining experience reminiscent of home. Patrons appreciate the laid-back ambiance, accommodating families with children, which further solidifies Garramone's as a beloved destination for both locals and visitors. Overall, Garramone's Restaurant is a must-visit for Italian cuisine lovers seeking an authentic dining experience infused with warmth and flavor.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Great wine list
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Garramone's Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Garramone's Restaurant

4.3

284 reviews

100%

33%

13%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 284 reviews

Garramone's Restaurant consistently earns praise for its high-quality Italian cuisine, with patrons frequently highlighting standout dishes such as chicken francaise, meatballs, and classic entrees like veal and chicken parmesan. The restaurant is often described as having a warm, nostalgic atmosphere that offers a cozy, hometown feel, appealing to families and those seeking a relaxed dining experience. Service is generally regarded as attentive and accommodating, contributing to a positive overall visit. While the food quality and welcoming environment receive strong acclaim, some feedback suggests that the establishment could benefit from interior and exterior updates to enhance its ambiance further. Additionally, parking availability has been noted as a minor inconvenience. Overall, Garramone's is valued for its delicious, comforting meals and friendly setting, making it a favored choice for both everyday dining and special occasions.

Artessa Andy

Jun 26, 2025

Came for Father’s Day everything was delIcious.

Neil Farber

Jun 24, 2025

The food is absolutely delicious! The best Trifecta ever! (That's what I call this dinner of(Lobster tail ,Chicken parmesan and Steak! My wife loves the Veal parmesan! And of course the wine and cocktails!!

Heidi Barrett

Jun 21, 2025

The chicken francaise was amazing tonight & I heard zero complaints about the meatball tunnel which was loaded! Thankful that we're so close!

PJB

Jun 17, 2025

My last visit was beyond expectations. The food was great, especially the meatballs. My only complaint is that they need to invest in some interior/exterior upgrades.

Kevin Groff

May 28, 2025

So I tried a new place tonight. A very nice and quiet place. It's like walking back into time but that gives it a hometown feel to the place. They serve warm bread to start and then each of us got a salad before our meal. We bought our 13 month old and that wasn't a problem. There was 2 other Littles here with different families as well. We will be back someday. Only downfall they have is the parking lot is very rough and water logged after a snow melt or rainfall.

Patrick Bosworth

Apr 21, 2025

The tavern cut prime rib basted in a1 sauce is awesome...the service is very good

Christine Hartman

Apr 20, 2025

We love Garramone’s! Just recently had the cavitelli, baked, with meat sauce. It was fantastic! Best I’ve ever had. There was enough for 3 meals! Hubby had shaved steak sandwich which was also outstanding and enough for 2 meals.

Heather Adam-Cerri

Mar 29, 2025

April 26, 2024 Had a nice family supper at Garramone’s tonight, we were seated immediately , our server, Kerry was very attentive & great at explaining the various dishes! Thank you Kerry! I ordered the Fish Franciase dish.... DELICIOUS!!!! I strongly recommend!!! Family friendly atmosphere...great service and THEE BEST FOOD!!!!